As with everything created by man, nothing is ever perfect. (Maybe with the exception of a good air conditioner in the summer time.) But having said that, this includes any of the fictional stories written by those who have the courage and time to attempt a novel, short story, or humorous anecdote. Think about it. Take some of our greatest writers. Mehlville, Stoker, Dickens, Homer (not Simpson, although I am a huge fan); every last one of them have written incredibly original tales with unforgettable characters, and set in times and places that will stay in our memories for the duration of our lives. But, and this is a huge but(t), we can take any one of their stories and say, “Hey, if I had the chance, I would change this or that about this story.” That is what I want to talk about today.
I understand that there are some of you out there who will disagree with me, and forgive me Ms. Meyer, I am not attempting to besmirch your good name nor am I wanting to cast a gloomy cloud upon your story. I am just giving my humble opinion.
The character of Bella gets on my last nerve. There, I said it, it’s out in the open and if you are a teenage girl, I know that you are shouting profanity at your computer screen. That’s ok, it’s good to vent. Get it out, but while you are, let me explain why.
I have read all four of the books, I have seen the first two movies that have been made, and get the same thoughts either way. I think, to begin with, that she is way too stuck on herself. In the first book, she is way too standoffish for my taste. Yes, Kristen Stewart is a pretty girl. Not beautiful, but very pretty. Even with her natural attractiveness, her attitude in the movie and the book just got under my skin. She comes off as unapproachable in regards to the other students at the school. The only people that she initially warms up to are the rich, pretty kids. I know that there a people out there that will attribute her remote personality to “low self-esteem”, but I got to tell you, I think that excuse is more overused than the underwear I have on right now. To be honest, I think the biggest problem people have with self-esteem is an over-inflated one. People who avoid others because, and I quote one, “I’m just not comfortable around people like that.” Or how about this one. “I was brought up to be different.” This is my favorite. “We really don’t have that much in common.” What a load. These are just excuses for certain individuals to avoid those that they feel they are above.
My second reason is that Bella comes off as, not just aloof, but selfish. She never tries to look at the world through the eyes of Edward and his family. Yes, in the end when she becomes a vampire herself, she starts to understand the self-control it takes for them not to kill and consume her and all of the other humans around, but until that time, it’s all, “No, you won’t hurt me. Please, kiss me, hold me, let me be around you all the time, but no way do I want to marry you.” Get over yourself, missy. Give the man some space and believe him when he says, “I want to eat you.”
Along with the Cullens, she displays her selfishness with Jacob. Don’t start cussing again, I know the purpose behind why she doesn’t truly fall in love with him, but she sure does take advantage of his love for her. “Oh, please protect me, Jacob. Please don’t be mad, I want you around, but don’t kiss me, don’t hold my hand, listen to me whine about Edward.” She ain’t worth it, Jacob. Bail out, man.
If you can’t tell, I have been treated poorly by a female in the past, so I am letting a bit of that frustration out. It’ll be ok, though. I’m a big boy. In the mean time, enjoy the books and movies, but if you are a teenage girl, don’t pattern your life after Bella.
Let me know what you think,
The Hairy Piper
{ 1 comment }